HPMB Secures Unanimous Appellate Victory in Medical Malpractice Case

On November 4, 2026, the Appellate Division, Second Department unanimously affirmed summary judgment for our clients in a medical malpractice case stemming from injuries the plaintiff suffered during an emergency C-section.
The plaintiff brought a host of claims against the defendant obstetrician, including that she “rushed” a C-section delivery unnecessarily, that she negligently caused extensive vaginal and bladder lacerations due to her surgical technique, that she failed to discover these injuries intraoperatively, and that her departures all led to plaintiff having to undergo corrective surgery by another physician months later. We successfully moved for summary judgment in the trial court, which held that plaintiff’s own experts offered only conclusory opinions and improperly relied on a new theory of liability – namely, our client’s failure to use “methylene blue” to test for a bladder injury – that hadn’t been raised in the pleadings or discovery.
Plaintiff took her case to the Second Department, along with a 60-page brief that challenged every aspect of the trial court’s order. We were able to distill plaintiff’s arguments down to their essence in response, however, convincing the Second Department that each and every one of them failed as a matter of law under controlling precedent.
We specifically showed that it was entirely proper for our client to order an emergency C-section due to plaintiff’s late stage of labor and the breech presentation of her fetus, and that the kinds of injuries she suffered can (and did) occur without malpractice. We also showed that plaintiff’s methylene blue theory could not survive summary judgment regardless of whether it was timely raised, because our experts offered unrebutted proof that a minimal delay in diagnosis did not affect her course of treatment.
HPMB has now secured a string of recent appellate-level decisions reinforcing the rule that a plaintiff cannot get past summary judgment where her experts fail to adequately address the medical evidence or the reasoning of the defendant’s own experts.